Can You Believe This

emmie | 15:25 Sat 15th Dec 2012 | News

38 Answers

For once i am speechless.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-judge-prompts-outrage-after-saying-if-she-didnt-want-sex-her-body-should-have-just-shut-down-in-rape-case-and-reducing-sentence-of-attacker-by-ten-years-8414674.html

£50,000 Well Spent?

Ridiculous Quote

Answers

1 to 20 of 38

1 2 Next Last

birdie1971

Best Answer

The judge in this case may be well versed in the law but is clearly a complete ignoramus when it comes to human (and specifically female) physiology. By making such a statement he is tacitly blaming the woman for the rape. What a disgrace this man is to suggest such a thing. He's clearly not fit to judge cases such as this and as such should be disbarred.

02:28 Sun 16th Dec 2012

Go To Best Answer

emmie

Question Author

it's the judge who should be in jail.

naomi24

//Judge Johnson has since apologised for his comments.//

Not good enough. He's not fit for office.

emmie

Question Author

Just as bad, can't understand this at all

Judge Derek Johnson's comments, which echo those of outgoing U.S. representative Todd Akin, who used the phrase 'legitimate rape' and said women who are the victims of rape rarely get pregnant, have drawn widespread condemnation.

naomi24

Condemnation isn't enough. They should be booted out!

boxtops

I saw this one when it first came out - it says in the I today that he's been reprimanded. Stupid man - why do judges say these things?

emmie

Question Author

no wonder some women don't report rape, or if they do have this sort of person up on the bench, i know it's from the US, but haven't we seen Judges like this here, heaven almighty.

emmie

Question Author

the sheer ignorance of his comments makes me wonder if he is married, and if so what his wife thinks.

Mick-Talbot

Unbelievable, he should be made to step down.
Or put him in a cell with a sex starved sadistic lifer .........see if his body 'shuts down'

boxtops

He clearly understands neither the way the female body works, nor that some rape victims would just give in rather than risk a battering or worse. Idiot.