Donate SIGN UP

They Plan To Bring Em Down This Weekend

Avatar Image
DrFilth | 09:39 Thu 24th Oct 2013 | News
18 Answers
what a shame to scrap these landmarks there are groups working hard to save them but they just don't want to listen

http://www.salfordstar.com/article.asp?id=1996
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 18 of 18rss feed

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by DrFilth. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Question Author

.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qAJzE5KsGIg
Knickers ?

WR.
it's kind of hard to see cranes as having intrinsic value that would justify their maintenance. Dio people actually go to see them the way they go to see, I don't know, the Angel fo the North?

Are they of any use to the Community,
or just the Eye-sore they appear to be?
I don't find them an eyesore, I like industrial constructions (and wind farms too), the same as I like the Eiffel Tower. But they need to earn their keep one way or another.

Nice that companies have offered to "help restore them" but who will pay for their long-term upkeep?
The sad fact is that you can't keep everything and metal stuff like cranes doesn't only need restoration, they need expensive ongoing maintenance to keep them safe. They weren't designed to stand there forever, even in places where the cranes are still in use they need replacing eventually.
Question Author
they are not an eyesore they are landmarks and yes people do go to see them

if you watch the video you can see the old dock gates and some of workers that made the docks and listen to some good music

all the pubs and old streets . the factories all gone just the two cranes to show people that it was a proper busy working docks
.
.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NvSfDj-LeHw
They don't look particularly interesting or special.
Canary wharf seems to have managed to do it.

They dont need to be working, just safe.
Canary wharf was built when there was money to burn....not so these days.
I agree with you DrF, I think it's a shame to destroy these cranes and all they stand for.
They need to get rid of things like this - it makes the area look like a dockyard.

These days, the term 'dockyard' is used as a romantic label, but developers want it to be severtal miles away from actually looking like its label.

Similarly - how many housing developments to do you see referred to as 'Mews' properties. when there is nothing like a Mews anywhere in sight?

For the record, a Mews is an area, usually converted stables, where falcons used to be kept - the name comes from the noise these birds make which is similar to a cat mewing.

So - if you see the term 'Mews' being used - ask the Developers where the original Mews stood, and if they can't answer, sue them under the Trades Description Act!

Anyway - back to the original point - the term 'docks' is romancing, and should not include any or all references to what docks actually are - hence the need for the cranes to go.

For heaven's sake, the BBC has built an HQ here - how can they possibly keep passing it off as 'Manchester' when there is all this evidence or northern working-class oiks cluttering up the place?

Question Author
andy-hughes > For heaven's sake, the BBC has built an HQ here - how can they possibly keep passing it off as 'Manchester' when there is all this evidence or northern working-class oiks cluttering up the place? <

sorry andy never thought of that with them winning awards for their building -)

> From a distance, MediaCityUK looks like one of those sprawling faceless office blocks, shunted alongside bleak city squares, that were common in eastern Europe 50 years ago <


http://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2011/sep/01/carbuncle-cup-2011-mediacityuk-bbc
Pssst...Salford Quays is in Salford, not Manchester ;)

It's a shame they can't keep them, they are such a prominent sight in the area, especially as right near a main entrance to the Quays though they are a bit tatty so could have done with some proper maintenance if being kept.

I liked the reminder of the old docks as the area has changed so drastically. I used to live in the Quays and they never bothered me, they aren't that near any of the residential flat/houses, closer to office accommodation and the old Dock Office.

I think it adds character, especially with many modern tower of glass and metal buildings like the NV Buildings and office accommodation (and BBC and other other media companies), even the Imperial War Museum is a modern structure. I quite like the black anchor model up over the bridge into Trafford, albeit they aren't original structures.
Eve - "Pssst...Salford Quays is in Salford, not Manchester ;)"

My regular references to 'Manchester' are ironic I assure you - I am fully aware that Salford is not only not part of Manchester, I know it is a city in its own right.

I keep calling it 'Manchester' because that is what the BBC will have done to try and persuade the Hamstead luvvies to shift north - even with the massive relocation expenses the BBC doled out from licence payers' money, you'd never have got them north of Watford without passing their new home off as a sort of 'northern' version of London.
-- answer removed --
It's similar to the case of the headgear of Clipstone Colliery. They were saved from demolition by a vote in the local district, the majority of the people voting to save them actually coming from outside the area while the locals would have been quite happy just to have had the wheels set up at the entrance to the town. People are still arguing about who should is responsible for the up keep and maintenance while trees grow through the roof of the buildings and acres of land is going undeveloped because nobody knows whats going to happen,I mean who wants something like this sat at the bottom of the garden
http://www.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e5/Clipstone_-_Colliery_Headstocks.jpg&amp;imgrefurl=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipstone&h=1704&amp;w=2272&;sz=801&tbnid=W3paJVTEvnnq4M:&amp;tbnh=95&;tbnw=126&zoom=1&amp;usg=__apc8dsP9daVemzdU1XlV6V04svI=&;docid=yIMM0_pHy7D0pM&sa=X&ei=Z3ppUuP8HaPR0QWvuoHADQ&amp;ved=0CDAQ9QEwAQ

1 to 18 of 18rss feed

Do you know the answer?

They Plan To Bring Em Down This Weekend

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.