News1 min ago
Does This Put The Quest For Diversity Within The Police Service Back One Step?
54 Answers
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by anotheoldgit. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.AOG
It's not support...I'm simply trying to say that if you're going to apply a thought process to doctors who are Muslim, surely the same logic needs to be applied to doctors who aren't.
Similarly Beverley Allitt is not representative of the white female nurses, Shipman doesn't represent white elderly GPs and Bilal Abdulla is not representative of Muslim doctors.
It's not support...I'm simply trying to say that if you're going to apply a thought process to doctors who are Muslim, surely the same logic needs to be applied to doctors who aren't.
Similarly Beverley Allitt is not representative of the white female nurses, Shipman doesn't represent white elderly GPs and Bilal Abdulla is not representative of Muslim doctors.
AOG
Svejk suggested that he "wouldn't let any Muslims in the Army, Police, Airport Security, Baggage Handling, anywhere, in fact, where people's safety might be jeopardised"
THECORBYLOON then asked whether that should include 'hospitals, doctors, dentists drivers etc?' which is a valid point. If you exclude Muslims from the jobs Svejk listed on the basis that people's safety might be jeopardised, that list really needs to encompass a lot more.
Svejk - I don't think you have thought that one through.
Svejk suggested that he "wouldn't let any Muslims in the Army, Police, Airport Security, Baggage Handling, anywhere, in fact, where people's safety might be jeopardised"
THECORBYLOON then asked whether that should include 'hospitals, doctors, dentists drivers etc?' which is a valid point. If you exclude Muslims from the jobs Svejk listed on the basis that people's safety might be jeopardised, that list really needs to encompass a lot more.
Svejk - I don't think you have thought that one through.
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.