he's right, it's a dreary dirge that has to have its verse about crushing the Scots removed. Shouldn't a national anthem be about the nation rather than about its hereditary ruler and the British God who is imagined to be protecting her?
No-one has mentioned 'I vow to thee, my country'. I would very happily have that as my anthem, Scots could think of Scotland, Welsh of Wales, Irish of Ireland, English of England, mongrels like me of the whole caboodle - but all British and, when push comes to shove, that is what we are.
I'm not keen on the idolatry of the monarchy which our present anthem entails.