//white people as a group are not categorically disadvantaged by black people putting on a blacks-only show... if they were disadvantaged on a systematic basis then i would agree that they were suffering wrongful discrimination but they aren't... there's a whole city of theatres right outside that are not doing this... it's one night and one tiny theatre... i would suggest they are better off being left alone//
So would black people as a group be categorically disadvantaged by white people putting on a whites-only show? Even if there was a whole host of theatres not doing so? Even if it was just one night and one tiny theatre?
If so, please explain why, if the circumstances were identical, black people would suffer from this, whilst white people, apparently, would not?
Your argument simply does not hold water. What you are suggesting is that black people need to be able to operate discriminative policies, whereas white people don’t (and I can imagine the outrage if they attempted to do so). Discrimination is discrimination, no matter who the victims are. It is somewhat strange to argue that the way to help overcome discrimination is to introduce something that demonstrates just that – even if it is a one-off.
More than that, the justification for this is nothing short of offensive. There is a need, apparently, to create “…a safe, private space for an all-black identifying audience, free from the white gaze.” I am at a loss to know how you can defend such a statement. It implies that, should white people be present, the space would no longer be safe; that white people, by their nature, present a risk to the safety of black people; that their “gaze” is somehow intrusive and cannot be tolerated. The language is inflammatory, the practice is divisive and discriminatory. If white people made a similar proposition they would – quite rightly – be howled down and so should the black people considering this insulting nonsense. Because you believe they have a valid reason (which I do not agree with but that is neither here nor there) does not make it any more acceptable. It’s time for them to get over their “shared history of mistreatment” and begin living in the present.