Yes gen2 you are right - posters must give numbers of letters and clues, we are not psychic. Happen to have done this crossword, by the look of it inaccurately, think frank is right.
Although people do answer you without you giving the clues, it would be nice for the people who dont have the paper to have a chance to answer as well. Also we learn nothing by only ever seeing an answer.
Frank this is not being grouchy. This is a site to get answers to questions. It is not achieving much if questions/clues are not given. It restricts it to those with the puzzle in front of them, and it does not help anyone else to learn anything new, or to have a go at trying to get solve a clue.