Donate SIGN UP

The hat

Avatar Image
Tom Braider | 20:06 Wed 03rd Sep 2008 | Riddles
4 Answers
Adam, Brian and Charlie are in a room together; Adam and Brian have perfect eyesight but Charlie is totally blind. On a table in front of them are 5 hats: 3 red, 2 blue, otherwise identical. They all know what's on the table.

While Adam and Brian close their eyes � they don't cheat � the hats are mixed up, each of them takes one hat and puts it on and the remaining 2 hats are taken away.

Adam looks at Brian and Charlie and says, "I can't tell what colour hat I have on."
Brian looks at Adam and Charlie and says, "I can't tell what colour hat I have on."
Charlie says, "I'm wearing a hat."

Charlie was right. What colour did he say and how did he know?

Gravatar

Answers

1 to 4 of 4rss feed

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by Tom Braider. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Question Author
I meant to write, "Charlie says, "I'm wearing a red / blue hat." Anyway, Charlie says he knows what colour his hat is.
Yes. Charlie declares he is wearing a RED hat.

The only combinations where Adam and Brian cannot deduce a color for themselves are

Adam - Red, Brian - Red, Charlie - Red
and
Andam - Blue, Brian - Blue, Charlie - Red

In both cases Charlie is Red and declares it.
C must be wearing a red hat.

Explanation:

A looks at B and C. The only way A would know what colour hat he was wearing, would be if B and C both had a blue hat on - leaving only red hats remaining. A doesn't know what he is wearing so we know that B and C are not both wearing blue hats.

B looks at A and C and also states that he does not know the colur of his own hat. By the same assumption that we used for A, we know that A and C are not both wearing a blue hat.

Let's assume that C is wearing a blue hat. If this is the case, then B is not wearing a blue hat, otherwise A would know that he is wearing a red hat. B knows this, so if A states that he does not know the colour of his own hat, then B would know that his own hat must be red.

However, since B states that he did not know the colour of his own hat, C must be wearing a red hat.
*sigh*

It took so long to type the answer, gen2 beat me to it lol :(

1 to 4 of 4rss feed

Do you know the answer?

The hat

Answer Question >>