Donate SIGN UP

Is There No End To Their Sensitivity?

Avatar Image
anotheoldgit | 09:32 Wed 31st Dec 2014 | News
91 Answers
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2891375/Target-customers-call-store-apologize-black-actress-Quvenzhan-Wallis-malicious-use-white-models-advertise-Annie-inspired-clothing-range.html

Annie was previously a white girl with ginger hair, now a black actress is portraying her nothing wrong with that one may say, but then it is when this kind of thing kicks off.

What will be the fall out if we ever get a black James Bond, which has been suggested?

Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 91rss feed

1 2 3 4 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by anotheoldgit. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Why did you choose James Bond? Strange.
Because they are/were considering Idris Elba for James Bond.
The 'problem' is that the range of merchandising now available on the back of the newly released film is being modelled by a white girl, whilst the film portrays Annie as a black girl.

The advertisers should have maintained the continuity by featuring a black model.

You would have asked the question, in 1982, had a black girl modelled the outfits worn by Aileen Quinn....
Zac-Master

One of the leaked emails from the recent Sony hack, was from an executive, putting forward the idea of Idris Elba playing James Bond after Daniel Craig leaves the role.

Mr Elba was one of several names put forward, but 'certain people' have subsequently spent much of the past week frothing at the mouth, hollering 'It's PC gone mad' etc etc.
If Idris Elba played James Bond I would probably watch it. I haven't watched any of the others...
Yes yes, I was aware of that. What I meant was, why even mention James Bond in connection with the story. Why not simply stick to 'the fallout' which this story has created?
Try as I might, I cannot get outraged about a supermarket chain I have never heard of, thousands of miles away in another country.

What they do, or don't do is of no consequence to a British audience.
AOG

By 'their sensitivity' are you talking about those who say that Annie should be a white gingers-haired girl (as evidenced by the Twitter posts in the link), or those who have signed the petition calling for Target to change their advertising?

I think I might agree with you that people are being a bit over-sensitive. The number of Daily Mail readers who were spitting feathers because of the black stormtrooper in the new Star Wars trailer was absolutely pathetic.

Same with those who protested against the idea of a black man playing Bond.

Some people really need to re-evaluate what is important in life.

This campaign against Target's advertising falls into the same bracket as those banging on about Bond and Star Wars.

These are all FICTIONAL CHARACTERS...

People would be better served tackling real racism...there's plenty to go round!
I think that, as usual, jack has nailed the point to this debate.

It's more likely an attempt to drag some more publicity for a failed idea that sees this film heading for the dumpster so fast it's leaving scorch marks!
ummmm

I'm afraid I'm in the 'No' camp for Idris. I think he would make an excellent Bond...but the timing is all wrong. Daniel Craig is (I believe) contracted to appear in two more Bond films. Looking at the release schedule for the most recent Bonds (approx every three years), the first post-Craig movie could be up to nine years away.

Idris would be 51 by then.

So my objection would be down to his age, rather than ethnicity.

A shame, really.
Question Author
sp1814

/// Mr Elba was one of several names put forward, but 'certain people' have subsequently spent much of the past week frothing at the mouth, hollering 'It's PC gone mad' etc etc. ///

Who are these 'certain people' sp? Are they ABers because I don't think the matter has been discussed on AnswerBank yet, has it?
Question Author
ummmm

/// If Idris Elba played James Bond I would probably watch it. I haven't watched any of the others..///

That's a little racist of you, ummmm.
That is an ominous use of the word 'Yet'.
Sp, Daniel Craig will be 47 when the next bond film is released so going by your 'too old at 51' and your prediction that Craig has another nine years, would you care to re comment on Idris's unsuitability?
Why is that racist?
AOG - "Question Author

ummmm

/// If Idris Elba played James Bond I would probably watch it. I haven't watched any of the others..///

That's a little racist of you, ummmm."

I disagree,

ummmm may choose not to watch Bond films because she doesn't like any of the actors used, up to and including Mr Craig.

She may like Mr Elba as an actor, and admire his work, and tune in to see what sort of Bond he makes.

The issue of his skin colour, or that of the other actors is not in sight in her view - only, it seems, in yours.
-- answer removed --
Question Author
sp1814

/// I think I might agree with you that people are being a bit over-sensitive. The number of Daily Mail readers who were spitting feathers because of the black stormtrooper in the new Star Wars trailer was absolutely pathetic. ///

/// Same with those who protested against the idea of a black man playing Bond. ///

/// Some people really need to re-evaluate what is important in life. ///

/// This campaign against Target's advertising falls into the same bracket as those banging on about Bond and Star Wars. ///

/// These are all FICTIONAL CHARACTERS...///

/// People would be better served tackling real racism...there's plenty to go round! ///

Perhaps it is encouraged by the way some get upset at white people blacking up to play black roles or being offended by innocent shows such as the Black & White Minstrels?
Oh for gawds sake give it a rest man.
Question Author
andy-hughes
/// ummmm may choose not to watch Bond films because she doesn't like any of the actors used, up to and including Mr Craig. ///

/// She may like Mr Elba as an actor, and admire his work, and tune in to see what sort of Bond he makes. ///

/// The issue of his skin colour, or that of the other actors is not in sight in her view - only, it seems, in yours. ///

Oh so you have set yourself up to speak on ummmm's behalf have you Andy, but how on earth do you know what is in her mind?

Or even mine it would seem.

Best to stick to things that you definitely know of.

1 to 20 of 91rss feed

1 2 3 4 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Is There No End To Their Sensitivity?

Answer Question >>

Related Questions