Anti-Semitic Posts V Anti Islam Posts.

[Atheist]

It seems to me that AB has lots of OP's attacking Islam and Muslims in general, but not many OP's attacking Jews.

Anti-semitism seems to be considered shocking, but anti-Islam seems to be considered quite acceptable.

What do you think?

[Countrylover]

Naomi, you are one of the rudest people now on this whole matter.  The difference is you do it in a cloaked snidy way just as you have now done to Ellipsis.  You certainly don't debate!  You just try to put down those that don't agree with you.  

[douglas9401]

Does a lovely candlelit supper though.

[Ellipsis]

> Incidentally, ellipsis, being a 'Cambridge mathematician' is no guarantee of common sense.  It just means, as my Oxford mathematician friend would have it, that you're quite good at 'sums'.

A mathematician does know about what is and isn't logical - without having to know anything about Islam or any other religion.  That's the nice thing about logic - as you should know, if you were logical. Ask your Oxford friend ... in fact, show them page 4 of this thread and show them where you went wrong ...

[naomi24]

Candlelight in this house is dinner, Douglas.  Dear old Mrs Bucket does the candlelit suppers.   ;o)

[douglas9401]

Bang on, etc. X

[naomi24]

Ellipsis, nonsense.  You put too much faith in what you think you know.  

[Atheist]

Naomi. A mathematician is not simply someone who is good at sums. I hope you appreciate that.

[Ellipsis]

You do not have a coherent argument, Naomi.

[THECORBYLOON]

I've just seen mention of a £1,000 challenge made by KHANDRO, what's that about?

[Atheist]

Yeeah. Tell us!

[naomi24]

Ellipsis, you haven't offered a reasoned response to my argument at all - not one.  The OP forgotten,  Islamic terrorism forgotten, I  find myself, once again, on the receiving end of personal abuse from those who are never capable of anything more.   Hey ho.    ;o)

[Atheist]

Naomi; Tell me who's personally abusing you and I'll have a go at them.

[Ellipsis]

> Ellipsis, you haven't offered a reasoned response to my argument at all - not one.

I have made my best stab at reasoned responses to your incoherent argument.

[naomi24]

If that's your best I can only suggest you try harder, ellipsis.

[ClareTG0ld]

There's no sense in trying really, ellipsis, but thanks for the efforts anyway. Same to countrylover :)

[Khandro]

Anyone who doesn't understand why Islam and Western culture are incompatible knows little of either or of history.

The West has been struggling against Islamic attacks since the 13th century & it has sometimes been a close run thing (Vienna, Toledo etc.) Now, suddenly the liberal-left are welcoming them in with open arms.

Islamic fundamentalists are no longer 'under the bed' they are, thanks to you useful idiots, in the bed, & almost everyone in power is frightened to even speak about it.

Three British MPs now require 24/7 police protection we are told, but what no one dare say, is from whom do they need it !

[THECORBYLOON]

I've found KHANDRO's challenge.

"Atheist; If you can direct me to an account of a Jewish grooming gang, I'll give you a thousand quid."

[ClareTG0ld]

On the other hand, anybody who refers to "Western culture" as if it were a single, unified thing -- in the face of, presumably, an equally singular Islam -- is clearly far less well-informed than they'd wish to make out.

It's a dangerous narrative, and one that again echoes, uncritically, the rhetoric of Islamist extremists.

[Khandro]

I ask again; from which religious group do these British Members of Parliament need protection from those who cannot be named ?

Clue: They are not Buddhists, Jews, Hindus, Christians, Sikhs, Taoists, or Zoroastrians.  

[brainiac]

Exactly, Khandro - and I reckon your £1,000 is quite safe.