Football In the news again, yellow cards, 10 minutes in the Bin??

[R1Geezer]

Saw on Sky News at lunch that they are talking about the old 10 in the bin for a yellow. I think it will improve the discipline and transform the game immesurably, what do you think? Easy BGB's available here. Oh and before some pedant moans about this being in news, it is news ok!

[sherminator]

yeah i like the 10 in a bin idea if its a dodgy foul that isnt quite redable but will give another team good advantage then im all for it!

definitely good for divers as well!

[sherminator]

also R1 you never came back to me bout camerons U turn

[R1Geezer]

just got back to you, sherminator.

care to have go at answering the question, newsdesk? Sin bining rubbish you say, like most of the little girly faggots that play p00fball? Can't you see beyond the end of your nose, think about it go on, I dare you,l employ that brain cell. What a titfer tat!

If the whole team gets punished then managers will reign in the players and stop them abusing the ref, arguing with desicions, diving etc etc anything that produces a yellow card now will be reduced dramatically. As rugby was mentioned it's worth pointing out that Rugby averages less than one yellow per game since the bin was brought in.

[R1Geezer]

well I wouldn't be rolling around in agony because I've split an eyelash anyway mate. Football is ok as a sport similar in strategy to hockey or netball, but it's the numpties that play it that put me off. It may be popular but hey so is the Sun!

[Gromit]

The rules of football are constantly evolving, and changes that improve the game are welcome.

I like the sin bin idea because the punishment favours the opposing team. Currently, if a player commits a foul and is carded he stays on the pitch. When he has accumalted five, he is suspended from his next match. The only people who gain from this is the next opposing team who have not been subjected to any foul play. They can an advantage which is not merited. Under the sinbin idea, he is off the pitch, thus giving the opposing team who have been the subject of foul play, the advantage.