ChatterBank0 min ago
What's going on with energy saving bulbs?
13 Answers
I've just bought a couple of Osram Duluxstar energy saving bulbs at my local Co-Op.
The package shows symbols which indicate that the 11 watt rating of the pearl bulb is equivalent to a 60 watt conventional tungsten filament lamp. To my mind, this can only be interpreted as the 11 watt energy saving bulb has the same light output as a 60 watt conventional lamp.
I wanted to see how true this claim was and I rigged up a length of cable with a lampholder and hung it on the ceiling (I've got halogen fittings in the room) and tried the energy saving bulb first then a pearl 60 watt bulb afterwards.
To my amazement, the light output from the energy bulb is nowhere near as bright as that from a the equivalent filament lamp.
What's going on here? Are these energy-saving bulb manufacturers guilty of representation? Shouldn't they have to clarify this in more detail as it seems the obvious interpretation of the symbols is not correct? Is it the light output that should be compared or is it something else?
If the government expects us all to switch over to these bulbs within the next few years they had better get these manufacturers to get their act together.
Until it's sorted, I won't be buying any more.
The package shows symbols which indicate that the 11 watt rating of the pearl bulb is equivalent to a 60 watt conventional tungsten filament lamp. To my mind, this can only be interpreted as the 11 watt energy saving bulb has the same light output as a 60 watt conventional lamp.
I wanted to see how true this claim was and I rigged up a length of cable with a lampholder and hung it on the ceiling (I've got halogen fittings in the room) and tried the energy saving bulb first then a pearl 60 watt bulb afterwards.
To my amazement, the light output from the energy bulb is nowhere near as bright as that from a the equivalent filament lamp.
What's going on here? Are these energy-saving bulb manufacturers guilty of representation? Shouldn't they have to clarify this in more detail as it seems the obvious interpretation of the symbols is not correct? Is it the light output that should be compared or is it something else?
If the government expects us all to switch over to these bulbs within the next few years they had better get these manufacturers to get their act together.
Until it's sorted, I won't be buying any more.
Answers
1 to 13 of 13
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by neuron. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
There is a chart here that explains.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compact_fluoresce nt_lamp
And you do need to give 'em a couple of minutes.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compact_fluoresce nt_lamp
And you do need to give 'em a couple of minutes.
-- answer removed --
there are three important things to realise about low energy light bulbs.
1. these bulbs are fluorescent bulbs in miniature and like all fluorescent bulbs they require 5 to 10 minutes before the internal fluorescent coating makes the bulb give out its full power.
2. because they take time to deliver their full light output they should only be used in places where the lamp will be on for some time ( they are not suitable in toilets or other rooms, where after a few minutes the light is switched off as they will never be on long enough to give out their full power ).
3. because these bulbs are fluorescent tubes in miniature you should never use them with ordinary dimmer switches, they will damage ordinary dimmer switches in a very short period of time. special dimmer switches are made for use with fluorescent lights but they are very, very expensive.
1. these bulbs are fluorescent bulbs in miniature and like all fluorescent bulbs they require 5 to 10 minutes before the internal fluorescent coating makes the bulb give out its full power.
2. because they take time to deliver their full light output they should only be used in places where the lamp will be on for some time ( they are not suitable in toilets or other rooms, where after a few minutes the light is switched off as they will never be on long enough to give out their full power ).
3. because these bulbs are fluorescent tubes in miniature you should never use them with ordinary dimmer switches, they will damage ordinary dimmer switches in a very short period of time. special dimmer switches are made for use with fluorescent lights but they are very, very expensive.
Thanks all for your replies.
I realised from the outset that these bulbs had to be on for 10 minutes or more to achieve their quoted light output and I should have made that clear in my initial post.
However, even after abiding by this 10 minute rule, I still find the light pathetic in comparison to incandescent bulbs. I don't know how these manufacturers can get away with these lies.
Yes, I could get a 18 Watt energy saving lamp that's claimed to be equivalent to a 100W incandescent lamp and then put up with something that's truly only about equivalent to a 60W incandescent lamp. However, the point is that these people claim that 11W is equivalent to 60W. Why can't they just get it right in the first place?
I realised from the outset that these bulbs had to be on for 10 minutes or more to achieve their quoted light output and I should have made that clear in my initial post.
However, even after abiding by this 10 minute rule, I still find the light pathetic in comparison to incandescent bulbs. I don't know how these manufacturers can get away with these lies.
Yes, I could get a 18 Watt energy saving lamp that's claimed to be equivalent to a 100W incandescent lamp and then put up with something that's truly only about equivalent to a 60W incandescent lamp. However, the point is that these people claim that 11W is equivalent to 60W. Why can't they just get it right in the first place?
In both my tenanted properties and my home, I've not had to replace a single low energy light bulb for more than four years.
Neuron, I think you are being unnecessarily inflammatory by saying that the manufacturers are lying. They would have been brought to book by now if lies are being told. Perhaps your expectations of these light bulbs simply do not fit the actual specification.
Neuron, I think you are being unnecessarily inflammatory by saying that the manufacturers are lying. They would have been brought to book by now if lies are being told. Perhaps your expectations of these light bulbs simply do not fit the actual specification.
1 to 13 of 13
