> Giving an opinion is fine when it's asked for.
OK, much though I dislike what sqad and naomi wrote, I do have to agree with them that posting on AB is in itself asking for an opinion (or a factual response where appropriate). I think the real problem is that what they wrote was so off topic and unhelpful to the OP; the response the OP was looking for could be interpreted in several ways, none of which were "Please have a go at me / AB". This was after all a post in Body and Soul, one of the more serious categories where some OPs need skilful help which sqad is very good for in the "body" department - sadly less so the "soul", it appears ...