The article is right. There is no economic benefit from further immigration. Each extra person in the economy is just another person, they do not add extra beyond that.
But adding people is not a neutral act. England has one of the highest population densities in the world. Despite this, the comments show that many people do not believe that a population density of 1023 people per square mile - 4 suburban gardens per person - is "overpopulated". They deny that reducing the amount of land per person makes us all poorer. These comments are remarkable because land area per head is a measure of wealth. Denying that loss of space makes you poorer is equivalent to saying that if I take half your cash you believe you are no poorer in economic terms and it is proof of muddled thinking.
Some of the people who commented are globalizers and believe that everyone has the right to exploit other countries (hating people who believe that "an accident of birth gives them rights to a section of the planet"). Britain is the home of the die hard imperialist so we should expect comments of this type.
Lastly there are horribly confused or frankly racist comments such as: "a lot of service areas would fall apart if it weren't for immigrant health workers". The article is about current and future benefits of immigration to the economy. Those who believe that the NHS can only function by perpetually replacing the current set of immigrant workers, often from ethnic minorities, by a new set of workers from Eastern Europe are racists of the worst sort. The terms and conditions of working in the NHS should be such that the current staff are kept in post and not endlessly replaced.
Given that it is the globalizers who hate this article, there is another article on the site called "The Future of Globalization" that considers our ecological footprint. It might help them to see the problem with globalization and overpopulation. See
http://pol-check.blog...of-globalization.html Media URL: http://pol-check.blogspot.co.uk/2012/01/future-of-globalization.html
Description: