I went to the Caribbean for the first time last Christmas, spent 2 weeks in Antigua and was absolutely blown away but that's because I want to spend all day every day on the beach and there are so many to choose from, some with only about 4 other people to share it with. Wouldn't recommend if you are after repeated fine dining and lots of other activities although there are lots of great beach bars and restaurants that do good but not posh food. I've already booked our return trip. It#s quite quiet but stunning and BA and Virgin fly direct from Gatwick..