Donate SIGN UP

What Do You Think Of The Idea Of Women Only Train Carriages?

Avatar Image
sp1814 | 05:39 Wed 26th Aug 2015 | News
57 Answers
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/jeremy-corbyn-labour-leadership-women-only-carriages-sexist-harassment-10471716.html

I can see why Corbyn has proposed this, but am not sure it's the right solution.

What are your thoughts?
Gravatar

Answers

41 to 57 of 57rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3

Avatar Image
I don't see why we shouldn't have Women-only trains - after all we already have Virgin trains !
17:21 Wed 26th Aug 2015
Except maybe on the weekends?
I don't think it is workable,also I fee safer in a mixed group.

Woman en masse can be very scary.
Just as a point of information, when "Ladies Only" accommodation was provided on trains it was usually on the "compartment" stock. Older readers will remember that such stock was divided into small compartments, each one with its own door so that access was only available at stations. There was no access between compartments. The "policing" was thus carried as at the stations as people boarded the train.

This is a particularly fine example of compartment stock which used to operate on the London underground system:

http://www.bluebell-railway.co.uk/bluebell/bash/hist.html

And this is a more recent version which ran on Southern Region commuter services until about 1995 (though not all of this type were compartment stock):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Rail_Class_415#/media/File:4EPB_set_at_Wimbledon.jpg

As far as I know no regular rail service operates compartment stock any longer and almost all conventional stock has access available between carriages.. Even if the idea was deemed desirable the impracticalities of it are probably sufficient to make it a non-starter. However, Mr Corbyn cannot claim the credit for this idea. It already operates in Japan and some other countries:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women-only_passenger_car

And Claire Perry, MP, floated the idea for reconsideration here last September:

http://www.citymetric.com/transport/uk-may-get-women-only-train-carriages-344

The facility was scrapped in the UK in the mid 70s I think. To reintroduce it today may need some enabling legislation as it would probably fall foul of gender equality laws. But I think the idea that the only way to keep ladies safe on trains is to provide them with their own carriage is a little misguided. Such facilities would probably prove quite an attraction for those slimeballs who are intent on harassing and assaulting women by quite conveniently arranging for a whole carriage to be the focus of their obnoxious behaviour.
I can remember corridor trains having Ladies Only compartments. It used to p... me off when travelling to my unit as usually the only available seats were in such compartments whilst I had to stand. Standing all the way from Newcastle to Hereford is no joke.
These would be compartments with a door on one side and corridor running along the other then, jackdaw? Certainly some of those had the green "Ladies Only" triangle.
[And I meant to go on before hitting the wrong button]:

These of course are no longer in use with almost all stock now being of the "open" variety.
SP, fry and his ilk have the same political agenda as many judiciary and I'm pretty sure you know exactly what I was getting at.
Having traveled on the 'Vomit Comet' from Kings Cross many times I can assure you women outnumber men in the 'drunk and incapable' league.
I'm sure you're right, Eddie !

We have a similar service from London to where I live (goes under the name of the "Pi55head Special"). The number of "Young Ladies" using that service who, shall we say, are "tired and emotional" has increased considerably in recent years and they really are far more obnoxious than their male counterparts.
I would welcome carriages where no children were allowed -last time I went on a train I had a family opposite who for two hours mopped up sick and changed putrid nappies on the table.
Question Author
Sorry Retrochic - we shouldn't have given Merlot to our three year old...
Mush...I rarely travel by train, as I have very little reason to do so. But I do get the Swansea to Paddington about once a year, and this still had a Buffet the last time I went, which was about a year ago.

This idea is daft, as most on here today have admitted. By this time tomorrow, we will have forgotten about...today's newspapers, tomorrows fish and chip wrappers, as the saying goes.

What the railways need to do is to concentrate on running a punctual service with a seat, on un-crowded and clean trains. without charging exorbitant amounts of money.

The last time I went up to Town and back by train, it cost my employer over £200 !
I wouldn't worry too much - with Corballs in power, there would be no trains as the NewBritishRailways staff would be permanently out on strike.
I don't see why we shouldn't have Women-only trains - after all we already have Virgin trains !
Question Author
mikey4444

£200???

Perhaps next time, go by public transport - not a coach 'n' four, with liveried footmen?
Question Author
Once again - Canary42 waits until the dying hours of the game, shoots and scores.

Well deserved 'Best Answer'.
Question Author
Err...for 'hours' read 'seconds'.

41 to 57 of 57rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3

Do you know the answer?

What Do You Think Of The Idea Of Women Only Train Carriages?

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.