Adele Upsets The Genderless Brits...

[naomi24]

//Adele is accused of being 'anti-trans' after telling genderless BRITs she 'loves being a FEMALE artist' but legions of fans and PR experts praise her for 'standing up for women' during prime time slot on super-woke ITV//

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10493529/Adeles-snub-virtue-signalling-record-label-chiefs-woke-LA.html

Good for her. Oops! Maybe I shouldn't have said that.

[Mamyalynne]

Yes, I am happy in my own views Pixie and whilst I may ask someone to clarify theirs, I wouldn't do so repeatedly over a protracted length of time.

It seems to halt healthy debate and look like an interrogation.

[pixie374]

No, you are right- that is exactly what is is.
A woman is biologically a woman, she,her... absolutely no choice and vv.
My question- which is one you actually have never ever answered, how ever many times I have asked....
Is what is a woman, even just gender wise? I just cannot seem to get and answer feom you for that.
Tbf, it isn't only you. It's over 7k people. Over 5k, don't want to answer at all :-). Some admit they don't know. And a handful give a list of stereotypes. Are you in the "won't answer"?

[pixie374]

Ah mamya, I forgive your misunderstandings :-) I'm very laid back!

[jim360]

// A woman is biologically a woman, she,her... absolutely no choice //

Yes, but having established that your definition is primarily focused on biology, and mine on gender, which you know how to define, I'm sure you can see the problem.

You can go on about how I haven't answered as many times as you like. It's simply not true. I'm sorry that you think otherwise.

[andy-hughes]

Mamya - // It's always been the case that when you say 'I love...' an odd bod will chip in with, 'So you hate...'. //

There's a Rule covering that.

[douglas9401]

In a few short years the sisters will be doing it for themselves since their quota's been cut.

Something like the MOFOs

[pixie374]

No, no, Jim. I fully get that.
So.... why.... do you think gender is more important than sex?
Could you please give me one example... where anyone else would actually need to know.
And.... any examples where we might want to know sex instead?

Also, who decides what and how women actually feel? Would it not be better to actually listen to some?

[Mamyalynne]

I know Andy - is it one of yours?

I didn't buy the book, Mamya dances to her own beat.

Pixie, i don't have any misunderstandings.

[pixie374]

I'm not making presumptions Andy... I'm asking Jim questions while he seems willing to chat . That's all.

[pixie374]

Sorry then, mamya, I thought you were trying to shut us up :-)

[Mamyalynne]

Even I can't turn that tide.

[pixie374]

Good :-)

[Atheist]

Why is it so important to some here to know whether or not a human is male or female?
Does it really matter?

[jim360]

// Why do you think gender is more important than sex?//

I never said that it was.

// Could you please give me one example... where anyone else would actually need to know. //

"need" is too strong a word. But if you're socialising with someone then you might want to know a bit about them.

// any examples where we might want to know sex instead? //

Eg, when it's relevant for medical reasons.

// Also, who decides what and how women actually feel? //

Any individual woman decides how they feel.

// Would it not be better to actually listen to some?//

I do.

[pixie374]

Hmmm.... do you think there are any general similarities between males and females?
What is it that a "transwoman" has in common with women, but not with other men?

I feel like we should be moving past stereotypes now, and just allowing people to be.

[pixie374]

From your last post, Jim.
A man having a blood transfusion from a mother, can be fatal. Should people "sometimes" be seen as women... but not always?

[bednobs]

"A man having a blood transfusion from a mother, can be fatal."
eh?

[Mamyalynne]

//However, a spokesperson for NHS Blood and Transplant told The Telegraph the study did not conclusively prove blood donations from women who had been pregnant necessarily posed a risk to male recipients.//

% year old link.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/blood-tranfusions-pregnant-women-kill-men-study-trali-journal-american-medical-association-a8006946.html

[Mamyalynne]

* 5 year old

[pixie374]

Not that confusing, bednobs, nothing you don't already know.
https://www.webmd.com/men/news/20171017/is-blood-donated-by-mothers-less-safe-for-men