Thoughts On This Song I Wrote?

[sheminith]

How are my vocals here? Are they "dont give up day job pal" worthy.. or fine? Also how song? Any feedback great :)

 

?si=GHdgJhxn5HgUw1NV

[Maydup]

If insists we sign in..... 

[sheminith]

Maydup.. im not sure where people get this from :/ there is no sign in necessary to watch any youtube link ever. This a youtube link. You can simply press on the embedded vid anyway

[Old_Geezer]

They seem ok for a pub singer, either folk or rock. Unsure they are yet operatic quality. My inexpert thoughts are that your voice is fine to continue to develop over the course of your career. Have faith in yourself.

[Ken4155]

Isn't this the same thread you posted back in Sep 2023? I've listened to both and cannot detect any differences, unless they're too subtle for the untained ear to discern.

[Old_Geezer]

That's a thought. Was the main point of this thread your vocals, or the song ?

[Clone]

What do you do for a day job?

[maggiebee]

Sheminith - don't bother asking on here. Most of them are old narrow minded Tories who wouldn't know a good tune or lyrics if it hit them in the you know what.  Go on to music sites to get an honest, sensible response.  They even stalk you to see what you put up before hahahaha